Dog Harness vs Collar: The Pros & Cons

Dog Harness vs Collar: The Pros & Cons

Walking with your dog several times a week has social, mental and physical health benefits. It can be great fun to be outdoors with your pet. It’s an exciting way to energize and unwind as you discover new sceneries and connect with new people. Sadly, your dog can get overexcited, especially when walking along busy streets. Use a dog collar or harness to control the dog’s movements when taking that blissful walk. Listed below are the pros and cons of a dog harness vs collar you should know.

Benefits of a Dog Collar

Dog collars are the basic pet control gear. Despite having existed for years, they’re still relevant today. Many dog owners choose a collar over a harness for the following reasons:

1. Collars are Affordable

Collars are cheaper alternatives to harnesses and other types of dog gear. Discover collars from your favorite brand at BlackPaw for as low as $15. The good thing is you can select from various materials and styles regardless of your budget.

2. Easy to Use

Collars are lightweight and portable. They easily fit into your travel bag or pocket. Their lightweight nature means they can fit dogs of all ages and sizes. They rarely stress your dog’s neck but provide the desired comfort for your canine friends to enjoy long walks.

3. Collars Fit Better

A dog collar is the best option if you want to allow your dog to wander around and explore everything they find interesting. It does not restrict their movement as much and allows the dog to run and play as they like.

4. ID Tags on Dog Collars

Collars support adding ID tags. You can create a customized name tag and hang it from the collar. Even if your pup gets lost, it’ll be easier to track them using the information on their tags. 


Cons of a Dog Collar

Dog collars are worth purchasing but aren’t without a blemish. They have their share of shortcomings you should know before buying one.

1. Pressure and Neck Injuries from Dog Collars

Collars are lightweight and portable but aren’t fit for small dogs. They may put lots of pressure on their tiny and delicate necks, leading to injuries and pain.

2. Collars Can Easily Fall Off

If your dog is smart enough, they can easily wiggle out of the collar. Once the dog does this for the first time, it may become a recurring habit.

3. Collars May Not Be Suitable for All Dogs

If your pup likes to pull, you may not benefit from a regular collar. Pulling extensively for an extended period can choke the dog and hurt their neck.

Pros of a Dog Harness

Dog harnesses have existed for years, advancing in design and functionality. The modern and well-designed harnesses at BlackPaw combine performance, durability, and efficiency.

1. Even Leash Distribution

The leading benefit of dog harnesses is their even leash distribution. This option of dog gear distributes the force of a leash better. They are even more suitable for dogs that like to pull as you get more control over their actions, making the walks more fun for both of you.

2. Dog Training with a Harness

Professional dog training prepares your pup to be more liable and responsive to commands. If you’re not a pro, a dog harness can help you train your dog to stay on track as you take those joyous walks. It gives you better control over the dog’s activities. Just attach the leash to the front side of the harness to redirect the doggie’s attention back to you whenever they pull.

3. Harnesses Keep Your Dog Close

The most dreadful experience is to have your dog slip out of the collar and run away. If your dog is agitated or curious to discover new surroundings, it may be challenging to trace him back. Such instances are rare when using a harness to control your dog’s movements. It’s almost impossible for a dog to slip out of a harness.

4. Stronger and More Comfortable Fit with Harnesses

Harnesses come with a comfy mesh lining. The mesh lining offers the comfort and relaxation your dog needs when it becomes extremely hot and sweaty.

5. Fewer Back Issues

A harness does not put extreme pressure on your dog. Your dog won’t have to struggle with back pains and problems every time you go out on a walk.

Cons of a Dog Harness

Dog harnesses aren’t 100% perfect as they have their share of drawbacks, including:

1. Dog Harnesses Can Pinch the Dog’s Skin

When the dog harness is super tight, it can pinch the dog’s skin on its legs, causing discomfort. That happens mostly when your dog has short hair. Smaller harnesses can add unwanted pressure on the dog’s shoulders, causing pain and discomfort.

2. Harnesses Can Be Hot

Walking your dog in a harness during summer could spell trouble. This is because a harness makes the dog hot, especially in the Colorado heat. If your dog tends to get too hot in summer, look for a harness that offers cooling remedies.

3. Harnesses are More Difficult to Put On

It may not be easy to put on a harness on your dog, especially if they avoid things going over their heads. Many dogs get excited for walk time, so getting them to sit still to slip the harness on may be challenging.

4. Harnesses Can be More Expensive

This may come to no surprise, but dog harnesses can be more costly compared to a regular collar. Also possibly a con to some, a sturdy well made harness will last you and your dog years to come.

When choosing between a harness and a collar, it’s important to weigh crucial details. You must first ensure the gear you choose will fit your dog properly and deliver the comfort they need to enjoy long walks. You should also consider your budget and ensure you get the right gear for your dog regardless of age. Durability and comfort are also important considerations when buying a dog harness or collar.

Visit BlackPaw to discover the best collection of dog-walking gear, and choose what suits you regardless of your budget and needs.

Back to blog